Born in Michigan City, Indiana on May 7th, 1923, Baxter was the granddaughter (on her mother's side) of legendary architect Frank Lloyd Wright. Her father was an executive with the Seagrams Distillery Company. While she was still a child, the family moved to New York City and she lived a rather privileged life, attending the private Brearley girls' school in Manhattan. Driven to act by Miss Hayes' performance, Baxter convinced her parents to allow her acting lessons with famed Russian actress Maria Ouspenskaya.
These lessons paid off handsomely as Baxter was cast in her own first Broadway role at the age of thirteen! The 1936 show was called Seen But Not Heard. Baxter had an understudy during the run who loathed her and threatened to finish her off, so that she could be seen in the part herself! This experience stuck with Baxter as she continued to evolve as an actress and would one day come in quite handy.
When she was just sixteen years of age, she tested for Alfred Hitchcock (then new to Hollywood) for his upcoming film Rebecca. Impressive as the test was, she was deemed far too young to play opposite Laurence Olivier in the demanding role. Joan Fontaine was cast and Baxter returned to New York where she appeared in two short-lived Broadway plays (one of which was Madame Capet with noted actress Eva Le Gallienne as Marie Antoinette.)
Now a little bit older and more experienced, the determined actress went back to Hollywood and secured a contract with 20th Century Fox. She made her debut at age seventeen in the adventurous western 20 Mule Team, about mineral miner Wallace Beery,
then a big star.) That same year, she found herself in a supporting role opposite John Barrymore, one of the stage's most famous actors, in the film The Great Profile. 1941 brought Swamp Water, costarring Walter Brennan, Walter Huston and Dana Andrews as well as Charley's Aunt, a cross-dressing comedy that starred Jack Benny. Baxter played one of two ingenues involved in the antics of the story (that's her below on the far left.)
She was paired with Tyrone Power, one of the studio's most popular stars, in 1943's Crash Dive. In it, she played a young schoolteacher who is engaged to Dana Andrews, but who “meets cute” with Power while on a train trip and can't help falling for him in spite of herself. Power went directly from filming this picture into the U.S. Marine Corps in order to help fight WWII. He would be absent from the screen for nearly four years and his first movie, once back, would also be a key one in Baxter's career.
In the meantime, though, she continued working, often in films with a wartime backdrop such as Five Graves to Cairo with Franchot Tone
Another wartime film was The Fighting Sullivans, based on a real incident in which five brothers, all of the children in one immediate family, were killed during military action. It inspired the government to enact The Sole Survivor Policy which sought to prevent entire sibling groups from being eliminated due to armed service. This was also partially the inspiration for Steven Spielberg's later film Saving Private Ryan.
Before the nuptials, though, Baxter was cast opposite Bankhead herself when she was signed by director Ernst Lubitsch to do A Royal Scandal, all about the love life of Catherine the Great.
Also in 1946, she landed what would be one of her most important roles ever.
Tyrone Power, back from the war and making his return to the cinema screen, chose the Somerset Maugham story The Razor's Edge with which to do so. His leading lady was Gene Tierney, but Baxter had the meaty part of Tierney and Powers' friend who seemingly has it all until an automobile accident robs her of everything and she slides into alcoholism and more. Baxter drew upon the death of her little brother, who was taken at age three, for inspiration during her hysterical scene and swiftly began garnering praise. She won the Golden Globe for her role in The Razor's Edge and then went on to take the Oscar for Best Supporting Actress against the not-too-slight competition of Flora Robson, Gale Sondergaard, Lillian Gish and Ethel Barrymore! She and Hodiak had a daughter together, Katrina, and maintained the life of a Hollywood couple through the early '50s. As a contract player,
1948 also brought the last of her three films with Tyrone Power. In Luck of the Irish, she played a character named Nora. Baxter must have been drawn
She next starred opposite Dan Dailey in two consecutive movies, You're My Everything and A Ticket to Tomahawk, before being given what is probably her most famous role.
Baxter drew upon her own early experience with a dastardly
understudy, one who didn't even bother to be as duplicitous as Eve Harrington was, but who had made her intentions known, in her sketching of the driven character. When Oscar time rolled around, the film was awarded Best Picture, Best Director and several other statuettes, but only costar George Sanders won for acting (in a supporting role.) Studio execs had suggested putting Davis in for Best Actress
Following this, Baxter played Glenn Ford's wife in the golfing bio-pic Follow the Sun and then starred in the western The Outcasts of Poker Flat, neither film befitting
In 1953, a good decade and a half after her Rebecca
Hodiak and Baxter's marriage ended in 1953 and he went to New York to star in a Broadway play. The play was a flop, but his own reviews were terrific, leading to him being cast in The Caine Mutiny Court-Martial. That was a rousing success and gave his career a badly needed jump start. Unfortunately, as he was near the end of filming On the Threshold of Space in October of 1955, he dropped dead of a heart attack at the age of only forty-one. Baxter, who had blamed herself for the collapse of their marriage, couldn't have taken this very easily, but had to be strong for their young daughter.
For that same year she won another of her all-time most notable roles, one that stands for all eternity in the annals of camp, thanks to her vampy, old-fashioned approach to the part. The movie was Cecil B. DeMille's gargantuan epic The Ten Commandments, starring Charlton Heston as Moses and Yul Brynner as Rameses II. She played the delectable woman who was loved by both of them, though her affections were primarily for Heston. When he begins to question his heritage and considers becoming a hero to his people, she responds with the immortal line, “Oh Moses, Moses, you stubborn, splendid, adorable fool!”
Having lived as a star in Hollywood, used to all of the many comforts that such a position affords, she was stunned by the lack of facilities facing her. She was isolated and left to run a house with few modern conveniences and even less help. She would later write a popular book detailing this period of her life called Intermission. While married to Galt, she had two more daughters, which helps explain how they passed their free time in the bush! (The second daughter was actually born back in the States, where they eventually returned, though they moved from New Mexico to Hawaii, seemingly always on the go.) During a return to the film capital, her agent was able to land her a role in the hooty Walk on the Wild Side, a tawdry tale of drifter Laurence
Now the mother of three and married
Elderly Robert Young, who played the title figure with handsome James Brolin as a sidekick, was given a recurring love interest and that role fell to Baxter. In the pilot and for nine episodes after, she portrayed Myra Sherwood, an elegant and sensitive lady friend to Young (who was sixteen years her senior!) It gave the illusion, at least for that first season, that ol' Marc Welby was possibly still getting a little romance in his life. Her acting was sometimes
quite poignant during her appearances and she was given plenty of kicky late '60s clothing to show up in. She had, by now, long had a manner of sighing, dropping her shoulders and looking upward, a conglomorative gesture that was somehow uniquely her own and could be quite effective. Oddly, she would make a later episode in 1973 as a completely different (and terminally ill) character! After this, Baxter returned to the big screen again, but oh how things had changed.
After playing one of the killers on the esteemed series Columbo and guesting on Cannon, Banacek and Mannix, she played John Forsythe's wife in the Hallmark Hall of Fame movie Lisa, Bright and Dark, playing the mother of a young girl facing a nervous breakdown. (Kay Lenz played the daughter...) In the lengthy, star-packed miniseries Arthur Hailey's The Moneychangers,
Baxter married for the third time in 1977 and moved to Easton, Connecticut with her husband David Klee, a successful stockbroker. They bought a piece of property and went through extensive remodeling efforts to make the home reminiscent of the work of her grandfather Frank Lloyd Wright. Sadly, Klee died suddenly after only a few months of marriage. She would remain unmarried after this, but did continue to reside in Connecticut and was a patroness of the local arts there.
In 1980, she played an aging actress battling to do an early work of Jane Austen's in the Merchant-Ivory film Jane Austen in Manhattan. Her character's desire to turn the work into an opera is at odds with fiery director Robert Powell's plans to stage an experimental version of the piece featuring his newest muse (played by Sean Young of all people!) Her daughter Katrina Hodiak acted and sang in this film as well. This marked Baxter's final appearance in a feature film. During the early '80s, she worked on the miniseries East of Eden
The popular show gave Baxter an appealing, sympathetic role that allowed her to hobnob with the bargeload of guests that checked in and out each week, many of whom were once-great stars now past their prime. (Baxter is seen above right with Miss Jane Wyatt.) Stewart Granger, Eleanor Parker, Jose Ferrer, Joan Fontaine and even Elizabeth Taylor were among the many visitors to the St. Gregory.










